Osama bin Laden Would Love GOP Rants on Immigrants and Foreigners
Nine years ago, I wrote a column about Republican candidates for president doing the work of the most fanatical agents in the Middle East, such as ISIL, who want to instill fear in Americans, hoping to foster divisions that will tear us apart.
My Al Jazeera America column, reprinted below, addresses issues that resonate today in American politics even with the decimation of ISIL — often called ISIS in America.
America does best when we strive to live up to the ideals in our Constitution and Declaration of Independence, when we stand up to bigots and bullies, cowards and fear mongers, panderers and domestic philistines. We do best when we work to ennoble the human spirit, express regard for every person, and work to make tomorrow better than today.
Trump’s remarks inciting hatred of Muslims (and Mexicans) have made him ISIL’s chief recruitment officer. ISIL has no better friend than Trump, though his ignorance and narcissism blind him to this awful reality.
We are far from completing our journey to “form a more perfect union.” But we have made huge progress since 1787, especially since World War II, the watershed event in human history.
In the last 75 years, America integrated the military and higher education (but only some of our public schools), expanded the franchise to people of color (though that is currently under attack from Trumpublicans), ended whites-only property deeds (but not de facto housing discrimination), adopted same-sex marriage, entered what some call the Fifth Wave of feminism, provided under Ronald Reagan a pathway to citizenship for immigrants here without permission, and for most of that, those years largely protected each woman’s right to control her body.
All of that offends those who want to return America to the 19th Century and, in the Middle East, to the Ninth Century. But none of the overseas ideologues pose a threat to us beyond isolated acts of violence. Indeed, domestic terrorists are more likely to kill you than foreign terrorists, as you will read below.
All that the Middle East promoters of the claim that America is the Great Satan can do is harass us, hoping to shred our nation’s shared belief in democracy and the benefits of liberty for ourselves and our posterity so that we will destroy ourselves from within.
Those seeking office with a doom-and-gloom view of the world, with calls for mass deportations, who say “some folks need killing,” are doing bin Laden’s bidding to foster distrust of our democracy, whether they realize it or not.
Below is my piece from Dec. 17, 2015:
Listening to Republican presidential candidates on Tuesday night (Dec. 15), you would think that America has become a nation of wimps, cowering in fear for no good reason over a murderous band of Middle Easterners with little power to harm us.
Polls show strong support for Donald Trump, who wants to spy on mosques and ban all Muslims from entering the country. Ben Carson fears a Muslim president would follow Sharia, unaware of the most basic principles of our Constitution. Sen. Ted Cruz spreads sophisticated versions of the same un-American rhetoric and calls President Barack Obama “an apologist” for terrorists during appearances on conspiracy theorist Glenn Beck’s show.
All three, along with the other Republican candidates, say if elected, they will protect us from “radical Islamic terrorists.” But the reality is that their vile comments threaten America far more than those they attack.
The Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) is a pipsqueak. It has no capacity to occupy a single inch of American soil and never will. It is no military threat to America or Europe. All it can do is recruit foolish people to harry us with violent crimes that have no military significance.
Yet under the influence of such political hyperventilating, Americans express their fears to journalists and pollsters about this mouse that cannot even roar. Their anxiety is as ludicrous as the plot of the 1959 Peter Sellers farce about the fictional Duchy of Grand Fenwick invading Manhattan so that, by surrendering, it could get American aid for its wine industry.
ISIL’S Chief Recruiter
Trump’s remarks inciting hatred of Muslims (and Mexicans) have made him ISIL’s chief recruitment officer. ISIL has no better friend than Trump, though his ignorance and narcissism blind him to this awful reality.
ISIL markets the idea that Islam is under attack, persuading people long on zeal and short on good sense to embrace its apocalyptic fantasies that the end is near.
ISIL is an enemy not just of America and the West, but also of any Muslims who do not hew to its vision of religious piety, itself a murderous apostasy that offends the Prophet Muhammad and his teachings.
Carson, Cruz and others help ISIL by encouraging the idea that America and its allies are at war with Islam, something that George W. Bush and [Barack] Obama frequently emphasized is not the case.
Now the leading Democratic candidate, Hillary Clinton, has joined in. At a town hall last week in Waterloo, Iowa, after the massacre in San Bernardino, California, she pandered, saying, “It’s OK, it’s OK to be afraid.”
No, it is not OK to be afraid. And shame on her for saying that, lending credence to the modern Know-Nothings in the Republican Party.
Being afraid is what ISIL, the remnants of Al-Qaeda, and their murderous friends want. What they cannot withstand are smart responses that degrade their capacity and demonstrate American distaste for government violence beyond the minimum necessary in response.
What we should fear are pandering politicians. We should be anxious when politicians promise safety at the price of trashing our Constitution, our values and our history.
Anyone who has read the writings of Osama bin Laden and his ideological spawn knows that their objective is to get America to destroy itself by getting into endless land wars in the Middle East.
One in 110 million
So, let’s get some perspective and separate the deadly and evil stunts of ISIL supporters from the actual risks we face:
Our chances of being killed in a terrorist attack are one in four million if you go all the way back to 1995, which would include the Oklahoma City bombing by a right-wing American fanatic.
If you count just the years after 9/11 the odds drop to one in 110 million, Professors John Mueller and Mark Stewart show in their brand new book “Chasing Ghosts: The Policing of Terrorism.”
Since 9/11 attacks by the far right have killed 48 Americans, compared to 45 in attacks by people claiming to be jihadists, reports compiled by the New America Foundation show.
And what of Christian, Jewish and Hindu fanatics? How about the many murders at Planned Parenthood clinics by people who claim to be Christians seeking to impose their ideology on everyone else? Or what of the Jewish Defense League, whose leaders Irv Rubin and Earl Krugel plotted in November 2001 to kill Representative Daryl Issa, a California Republican of Arab descent. Years earlier the Rand Corporation think tank warned that “for more than a decade, the Jewish Defense League (JDL) has been one of the most active terrorist groups in the United States.”
More broadly, homicides claimed 16,121 American lives in 2013, with 70 percent of the victims shot to death, the federal Centers for Disease Control reported. So far this year [2015], 12,662 Americans have been shot to death.
[UPDATE: At almost 19,000 last year, that number has been rising much faster than the population since, a disturbing indication of how America is, as Osama bin Laden hoped, tearing itself apart.]
In this Century tornadoes have killed 49 Americans per year in this Century if you ignore the 553 deaths in 2011, which raises the average to 84. Lightning killed 26 Americans this year, which is more than the 14 victims of the San Bernardino mass murder and the five killed in Chattanooga last July.
Yes, tornadoes and lightning have proven far more deadly than impotent ISIL, but you wouldn’t know that from the exaggerated fear-mongering from our presidential candidates.
Leadership
Contrast that with what our leaders said in the past in far more worrying circumstances.
On the night of 9/11, in a national television address, President George W. Bush said, “Terrorist attacks can shake the foundations of our biggest buildings, but they cannot touch the foundation of America.”
More than a half century ago, when a nuclear-armed Soviet Union was an actual military threat, a new president spoke with determination about preserving liberty. In his 1961 inaugural address, John F Kennedy said “Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.”
That was not a call to arms, but to smarts. And key to those smarts was showing that freedom comes not from the barrel of a gun, but from a determination of each of us to protect the liberties of everyone else, especially those whose views we dislike.
In 1933, when the worst economic collapse in our history ravaged the nation, saying that “the only thing we have to fear is fear itself — nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advances.”
Where are the leaders today who will appeal to our best instincts? Who among the presidential wannabes operates from the position of strength that our national anthem declares in all four stanzas, written when a foreign Army had occupied the nation’s capital and was advancing on Baltimore?
We need leaders who will encourage us to stand firm, act smartly and promise that we will remain “the land of the free and the home of the brave.”
